November 15, 2026

997.1 vs 997.2 Carrera S: Why Is the 2009 Worth $20k More?

A 2009 Porsche 911 Carrera S sells for about $20k more than a 2008. One model year, one big reason: the engine. Here's how to check which one you're looking at.

997.1 vs 997.2 Carrera S: Why Is the 2009 Worth $20k More?

Look at manual Porsche 911 Carrera S coupes from the 997 generation and you'll see a strange jump in price.

A 2008 car sits at a market benchmark of around $49,000 on classic.com. A 2009 to 2012 car sits at around $67,500. Comparable cars often end up $20,000 to $30,000 apart.

Normally one model year is worth a couple of thousand dollars. Not twenty. So what's going on?

It's not the mileage, and it's not the options. It's the engine.

What changed in 2009?

The 997 generation of the 911 is split in two. Cars up to 2008 are known as the 997.1. Cars from 2009 to 2012 are the 997.2.

The 997.1 Carrera S used Porsche's older 3.8 litre engine. The 997.2 got a completely new engine with direct injection. It also made more power, around 385hp instead of 355hp, and the automatic switched from the old Tiptronic to the much better PDK gearbox.

But the engine itself is the real reason for the price gap.

The two weak spots in the older engine

The IMS bearing. The older engine has an intermediate shaft bearing, usually just called the IMS. On most cars it never causes a problem. But when it does fail, it can take the whole engine with it. On the later 997.1 cars it's estimated to fail in a small percentage of engines, so it's a risk, not a certainty.

Bore scoring. This is where the cylinder walls get damaged over time. It's the better-known issue on the 997.1 Carrera S, and it shows up most on the 3.8 litre engine.

The new engine in the 997.2 has no IMS bearing at all. Bore scoring can still happen, but it's rare, and it's a different kind of failure from the one on the older engine.

So the extra money for a 997.2 is really buying peace of mind on the engine.

How to check which one you're looking at

This takes about ten seconds.

Look at the VIN and find the tenth character. That's the model year.

  • 8 means 2008, the older 997.1 engine.
  • 9, A, B or C means 2009, 2010, 2011 or 2012, the newer 997.2 engine.

Don't go by the year written in the listing. In Europe, the 997.2 went on sale in late 2008, so some newer cars are registered as 2008.

And don't go by the lights either. The 997.2 has LED tail lights and LED daytime running lights at the front, but owners often fit the newer lights to older cars as an upgrade. The VIN is the only check you can't fake.

If you're buying a 2008 anyway

A 997.1 isn't a bad car. It's a cheaper way into a manual 911 Carrera S, and plenty of them are fine.

Just go in with your eyes open. Before you buy, get a borescope inspection from a Porsche specialist. They put a tiny camera into the cylinders and can spot scoring before it becomes your problem. It's usually a few hundred dollars, which is nothing next to an engine rebuild. Ask the seller whether the IMS has ever been addressed, and get the answer in writing.

My take

If it were me buying this car, I'd buy the 2009 (997.2) simply because I don't want to deal with the headache of going to a mechanic and getting a borescope inspection done. $20k is definitely worth the peace of mind for me + the extra power.

What do they cost now?

Manual 997.2 Carrera S coupes sit at a benchmark of around $67,500, and clean, low-mileage cars sell for more. Manual 997.1 Carrera S coupes sit at around $49,000. PDK and Cabriolet cars are generally cheaper than manual coupes.

Prices move, so always check recent sales for the exact car you're looking at, and get an independent pre-purchase inspection before you buy.

Sources

The 997.2 Carrera S is one of 20 cars on my watchlist of supercars I think are mispriced right now. Each one has something most buyers miss. Get the free list here.

FREE · 20 CARS

The 20-car watchlist.

The exact Ferrari, Porsche and Lamborghini chassis I'd buy this year — plus one line on why for each car.

Free. Lands in your inbox in a minute. Unsubscribe anytime.